February 20, 2019, 01:13:49 AM *
Welcome, Guest. Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
News: Guests can read some posts but have no other privileges.
Team members should register to see all boards.
Forgot your password?
   Home   Help Login Register  
Pages: [1]   Go Down
Author Topic: Prime Grid Motivation  (Read 4256 times)
Chris Rhino
New Member

Aussie Karma: +15/-0
Offline Offline

Posts: 22

« on: October 16, 2011, 12:55:51 AM »

Hi there all you Prime Grid Crunchers,
I don't currently crunch prime grid, I also don't plan on crunching it. I've done a few hours trying to research the motivation of prime hunters and am wondering what the individual motivations of my fellow boinc@austrlia crunchers are.
I will also say that the reason that I don't think I will crunch on this one is that I don't see that it can contribute meaningfully to science.
This is meant to provoke discussion, I'm not trying to denigrate your choice in crunching. Just curious.


Super Hero

Aussie Karma: +590/-0
Offline Offline

Posts: 2264

« Reply #1 on: October 16, 2011, 07:30:59 AM »

Different strokes I guess Chris.  The science is mathematics. My interest is that of an old crypto person albeit my time was before computers.  Is it useful science?  Perhaps so, perhaps not, that would depend on your point of view.  The project has gained the interest of mathematicians around the world.  Maybe it is just one of those "for interest" projects.
What it is though is a very well run, stable set and forget project, not hard on graphics cards or my ISP's monthly data limit.  In the pure numbers game it has helped our small team to stay within touch of the big BOINC crunchers.

The beauty of BOINC crunching is that there is a project for everyone.  I wish the medical projects would get into GPU processing but until they do prime hunting will have to do.

Thnak you for raising this subject Chris.  One of my pet hates is political correctness and that, I believe, is an evil that has robbed us of the freedom of speech.

Cheers Mate.

Super Hero

Aussie Karma: +235/-0
Offline Offline

Posts: 1010

« Reply #2 on: October 16, 2011, 09:15:36 AM »

Good question Chris Thumbs Up

I wish the medical projects would get into GPU processing but until they do prime hunting will have to do.

This is probably the main reason I run Prime Grid. I have an ATI gpu so there are only a few projects available for me. I like Prime Grid but would rather run a medical type project if I had the option.


Full Member

Aussie Karma: +28/-0
Offline Offline

Posts: 69

« Reply #3 on: October 16, 2011, 10:04:20 AM »

Hi all, whilst I don't crunch PrimeGrid, I do crunch for Collatz.
Motivation behind that is purely practical becuase I have ATI cards that dont support DP. That limits the choice of projects that are available.
Secondly, I wanted to choose a project that was stable and long-term.
By that, I prefer selecting projects that don't retire within a year and has long term viability.
To me, thats an inidication that a project needs lots of computing power.


Super Hero

Aussie Karma: +2023/-0
Offline Offline

Posts: 8812

« Reply #4 on: October 16, 2011, 10:51:56 AM »

I crunch Primegrid because I also have ATI cards and I am interested in Mathematical type projects.  I also crunch Collatz, and DNETC because I only have ATI GPU's except for one.  I also like the thought that when I find a new prime number it is recorded in an external register of Prime Numbers against my name. Remember it is only the llr work units that find new primes and there is no ATI application for llr.  Being the founder of the Team I attach to all the projects that the Team is crunching, usually when they are first created.

rank   prime    digits   who   when   comment
497   545 21185295 + 1    356813    L2724    Oct 2011    
640   1089 21111763 + 1    334678    L2724    Sep 2011    
5259   21703472276295 2666666 - 1    200700    L2512    Jul 2011    
16760   6321 2453116 + 1    136406    L837    May 2009    
16837   3351 2451825 + 1    136017    L837    May 2009    
16876   5185 2451006 + 1    135771    L837    May 2009    
22059   31330586439 2333333 - 1    100354    L328    Jan 2008    
23424   15336808641 2333333 - 1    100354    L328    Jun 2007    
24183   6616796595 2333333 - 1    100354    L328    May 2007    
« Last Edit: October 16, 2011, 11:01:00 AM by Dingo » Logged

AA's > 1-Malaria 2-Tanpaku 3-Riesl Siev 4-Seti 5-ABC 6-Einstein 7-WCG 8-Seti 9-QMC 10-WCG 11-Cosmo 12-ABC 13-MilkyWay 14-3x+1 15-Rosetta 16-ABC 17-MilkyWay 18-Einstein 19-WCG 20-WCG 21-POEM 22-Rosetta 23-Docking 24-Spinhenge 25-Alternate 26-Simap 27-Poem 28-Constellation 29-WCG 30-Edges 31-YoYo 32-POGS 33-WCG 34-SETI 35-POGS 36-POEM 37-POGS 38-Asteroids 39-POGS/MILKYWAY 40-SIMAP 41-POGS/Einstein 42-Seti/Seti 43-Asteroids/Poem 44 WCG/Einstein 45-POGS/Poem 46-WCG/Einstein 47-POGS/Poem 48-Asteroids/Einstein 49- CSG / Primegrid 50-POGS / Einstein 51-Citizen Science Grid / SETI 52- POGS / GPUGrid  53- WCG / MilkyWay 54- Universe / Einstein
Challenges: 1-Citizen Science Grid

Have a look at the BOINC@AUSTRALIA Facebook Page and join.

Proud Founder and member of BOINC@AUSTRALIA
Have a look at my  Web Cam of Parliament House O
Pages: [1]   Go Up
Jump to:  

Powered by MySQL Powered by PHP Powered by SMF 1.1.11 | SMF © 2006-2009, Simple Machines LLC Valid XHTML 1.0! Valid CSS!